Discussion about this post

User's avatar
Cheriton Bishop's avatar

Good advice Steve, the 321 rule is a must.

Lots of people do however confuse backups with the mirroring of files with a Cloud service (iCloud, OneDrive, DropBox etc.) or onto a NAS. [For brevity I will subsequently refer to the Cloud / NAS as a “Mirror”]. Although mirroring the contents of your Mac / PC is an excellent practice, it’s is NOT a backup since any changes to the file on the Mac / PC will be replicated on the Mirror. This is especially true when a file is deleted and/or corrupted; the deletion / corruption will also happen to the data on the Mirror.

The only safe way to ensure data integrity is to have both duplication AND backups. For example, data on my Mac SSD is mirrored / duplicated on iCloud and on a Synology NAS (which runs RAID 5, so has inbuilt fault-tolerance). The Mac data is also backed up separately via Apple TimeMachine - locations being two separate external HDDs and the NAS. The NAS is also backed up to two separate external hard drives and to Synology’s cloud backup service.

This way I have copies of my data available to all devices that can access the Mirror plus backups of this data on separate and disparate media, one of which is offsite. In addition the Mirrors also offer versioning, so I can revert to a previous version of a file if recent changes to it are “sub-optimal”.

It sounds complicated, but once set up it just ‘happens’ in the background.

Oh yes, I do also check that the backups can be read and restored 😀.

Expand full comment

No posts